Sample From Part One
“Brandi, the Freak,” Denise cried out. A former student of mine, she spent many days serving in-school suspension for picking fights and for swearing at teachers and other students. Lanky, dark-haired, and strong, she typically bullied her way through school, scaring kids and fighting anyone who defied her. A good four inches taller than Brandi, Denise probably would beat her up before anyone could stop her.
Brandi said nothing in response to Denise’s taunt. Instead she lunged at the taller girl. Falling to the floor in a jumble of painted fingernails and dirty shoes, the girls wrestled. Brandi, moving faster than I expected, given her bulk, gained the upper position. Sitting astride Denise, she commenced pummeling her head methodically, simultaneously bouncing on her belly. Brandi was a dirty little fighter. “So. I’m a fuckhead?” Brandi’s words came out in cadence with her bouncing. “Death to me? No way. I think. You’re gonna die. Greaseball.” On the last word, she grabbed a skein of Denise’s long hair and yanked, wrenching several strands from her scalp. “Bitch,” cried Denise. Saliva sprayed from her mouth. She squirmed but couldn’t dislodge Brandi. One of Denise’s sneakers fell from her gyrating foot and thumped to the floor. Brandi scooped it up and tossed it toward the bystanders congregating in the corridor outside the cafeteria. A big, blond boy caught the sneaker, and a couple of other boys cheered. Brandi held the hank of hair aloft. “Throw it,” somebody called. “Hey. Over here,” another boy yelled. “Okay, who wants it?” Brandi asked. Brandi played to her audience, who called out, whistled, and clapped in rhythm. She wound the hair into a wad, then cast it into the crowd. Blond boy caught it, and his buddies slapped him on the back. Brandi was quite a sight. She was big: not overly tall, but hefty for her height, about five feet four. Everything about her was round. Her face was full, with big cheeks, her nose was short and, if not exactly round, softened around the edges, and even her eyes, opened wide, sat like blue M &Ms on white paper plates. Her mouth was small and pouty, her lips covered in a light shade of gloss that, amazingly, still shimmered. Her smooth-skinned face glowed pale ivory with pink cheeks and sported a few freckles across the bridge of her nose. The good looks were there, just concealed behind the weight and the ugliness of her behavior.
Brandi’s arms and legs seemed shorter than they were because they were filled out with bulgy flesh, but no definition. Her thick body did not have a clear division of chest, waist, abdomen, and buttocks. All of the pieces more or less merged into one package, round and imposing. Her best feature was her hair. The color was lovely, although I wondered if she dyed it; later I learned it was natural. It was honey blond, a shimmering of various shades from very light brown to pale yellowish, the color that really looks like it was “touched by the sun.” The style, if you could call it that, was stunning, as well, but in a totally contrasting way. Brandi might have been striving for the spiked look, but either the fight or no idea of how to accomplish the effect resulted in a strange hair-do. The result was a mass of uneven clumps of hair protruding from her head, some of it matted, some of it separated into strands, all of it looking less like hair than a dirty mop. Brandi was one tough cookie. Finally Bob Lemieux, a burly industrial arts teacher, arrived and pulled Brandi off Denise. Struggling and sniping at her captors, Brandi had a nasty word or two for the bystanders in the crowd. As she moved by me, Brandi flashed a grimace in my direction and asked, “What you looking at, bitch?”
After the crowd broke up and headed to class, I recalled a reference to her a few days prior to the fight. At the beginning of lunch period on that particular day, I had walked into the girls' lavatory. A favorite hangout, it served as an informal lounge, snack bar, and beauty salon. I found no one there but noticed a line of graffiti strung along one wall. The words blazed in cherry-bright lipstick across the ocher cinder blocks: “Death to the Bitch—Your going to die—Brandi is a Fuckhead.”
School policy required any personal threats be reported to the principal, so I had notified the office. Shocking as the words sounded, students sometimes marked up walls with nasty, cruel comments, especially if more than one person collaborated or if one kid dared another. I had wondered who this Brandi person might be that she could elicit so extreme a statement. Having just learned the answer, I realized that Denise must have been the author, and Brandi had just inflicted her style of retaliation.
2
Several weeks into the term, Brandi transferred to my teaching team. She always dressed in jeans. At school there was a sort of teen-age fashion cult concerning the proper design, fabric, color, and accessories for jeans. Despite her extra weight, Brandi was as conscious of the style as any girl her age. She owned a wardrobe of jeans that ran the gamut of adolescent fashion-consciousness: flares, bells, straight legs, baggies, low-risers. As for her tops and her shoes, Brandi also showed herself a savvy dresser. The tops hung loose, in an attempt to hide her bulk, and were either sweaters or of jersey material. She wore both short-sleeved and long-sleeved tops, mostly in pale or, more likely, just faded colors: light blue, beige, lavender, green. She also owned the inevitable gray sweatshirt; she could wear that over anything, and it served as a sort of uniform for both boys and girls—jeans and a gray sweatshirt, a safe, blend-into-the-crowd kind of outfit. Although she owned acceptable Nikes, she preferred a pair of black leather platform shoes with laces and rounded toes. They increased her height at least two inches.
Each day in class I never knew what kind of mood Brandi might be in or how she would act. Some days she arrived sullen and remained quiet and distant for the entire class, though these occasions happened infrequently. More commonly she stormed into the room, her voice leading the way. Discord and unpleasantness followed her, then hung, cloud-like, over her head, a personal little storm.
At rare times she entered the room calmly, like most of the kids. One such day I instructed the students to write a personal narrative. “You’re not going to make us read these out loud, are you?” Brandi asked. When I assured her that only I would read the essays, she immediately set to work, writing for most of the class time. When she finished her composition, Brandi set down her pencil and lay her head on the desk. I left her alone until I called for the papers. Rising, she handed me her narrative without saying a word and left the room.
I forgot about her paper until the evening, when I was reading her class’s work and picked hers from the pile:
Each day I wake up and wonder will any body appreciate me for who I am. Thats the question! I look at myself in the mirror. Reflecting off me is a person wanting high education. I look at myself and wonder am I any good for someone. I look at other girls my age always trying to be like them. Wanting to be cool in my own way. Every time I look at myself striving to be better each day. Taking nonsense and sense and putting it together and becomes a life for others. I wonder will I be like them? I know that each day I get up and go to school. Everybody makes fun of me always saying there better than me. Maybe they are. I want to go to collage and my years in school are going fast. I know I’ll be what I am forever. I’ll be that person wanting more in my life. Will I ever get married or live in a rich mansion? No one can predict the future. But I know that if I was pretty and popular, guys would like me. I know somewhere there is a person just perfect for me. I wonder will I ever go to the prom or be popular?
Setting the paper on my desk, I thought about the disparity between Brandi the thick-skinned tough and Brandi the insecure twelve-year-old. A sensitive girl dwelled in there somewhere, and I vowed to scratch the surface to find out who appeared. I returned to school after Thanksgiving vacation, but Brandi did not. After three days, the seventh grade guidance counselor, Elaine Fowler, informed me that Brandi had run away from home. The parents did not know where she was, and, according to the counselor, they probably wouldn’t look for her because, “She’s run off in the past and always come back when she’s ready.” Elaine guessed that she had gone to Portland and joined the fairly large number of adolescent runaways who lived on the street, panhandled, andvisited the soup kitchen for one meal a day. “How will you find her?” I asked. “Hey, the parents don’t care. I tend to agree with them. She’ll show up when she’s ready.”
“Well, don’t you have to report this to the authorities? Doesn’t the school have a responsibility for her safety? "
"I’ve contacted the Department of Human Services. They take it from there—at least till she returns. Then we’ll have to meet with the DHS caseworker, her parents, maybe a social worker and a psychologist, the whole nine yards. "
"It seems so cold-blooded to let a twelve-year-old child fend for herself like that...” I began. Elaine cut me off. “Hey, nobody permitted her to go—she took off herself. Besides, this kid is a pain to everybody. She made it clear she has no use for us. I’ve got plenty of good kids who appreciate what I try to do for them. Besides, I say good riddance to bad rubbish.” She turned from me and headed toward her office
I taught my classes, noting each day that Brandi did not return. I knew I would hear from the principal when he got any news about her. As Christmas break approached and still Brandi had not appeared at school, I wondered what she was doing.
3
School resumed in January, and Brandi continued to remain among the missing. At the end of the month she returned, without fanfare. On a Thursday she sauntered into my classroom to a cacophony of comments and questions from the other students. “Hey, look who’s back. "
"Wow—where ya been, man? "
"Geez, I thought you were the smart one. But you came back, dummy. What’d you do that for? "
"Lookin’ good, lady, lookin’ real good.” This comment came from the loud mouth of Kevin Wiley, a big, heavy-set boy descended from a long line of woodsmen. He considered school a place to park himself until he turned sixteen. Kevin often waxed eloquent on the relative merits of chain saws, splitters, skidders, and cherry pickers, while he kept one of his pale green eyes perpetually focused for attractive girls. Brandi’s appearance startled me as much as it did my students. I was surprised by her return to school, more surprised by her looks. She was noticeably thinner, twenty pounds thinner, I guessed. With bulk reduced, her body had definition: hips, waist, and breasts. The round face had disappeared, replaced with more of an oval; high cheekbones stood out, and her lips appeared fuller. Her eyes sparkled as before, although they took on more prominence in the slimmer face. Somebody had styled her hair, which practically squeaked of clean and lay over her head in short, loose curls. The morning sun caught the golden highlights.
Brandi strutted in new clothes that fit properly and looked good. She wore jeans, a traditional cut that neither bagged nor trailed on the floor. Her shoes were black platforms with laces, but lower and less clunky than her old ones. A long-sleeved, light blue sweater enhanced the blue of her eyes and contrasted nicely with the red-gold of her hair. Brandi looked pretty. The class thought so, too. I noticed them watching her while she walked across the room to my desk. “Hey, Ms. M., I’m here.”
Both the boys and the girls were curious about the “new” Brandi. Everyone, it seemed, wanted to know where she’d been, what she’d been doing, what was going on. “You been gone so long, I thought you died. Ha. I guess you didn’t though. "
"Somebody told me you been in Portland. I bet you ain’t been nowhere.
You just been home playin’ hooky. "
"You really been livin’ on the street? "
"What’s it like?”
Fascinated by her unexpected disappearance, her classmates asked if Brandi could share her experience of running away and living on her own. I asked Brandi if she wanted to tell us what had happened to her. She shrugged and said, “Okay,” but I thought her smile belied the blasé response. Most of the students wanted to hear Brandi’s story. I anticipated many questions, so I told the class to save comments and questions until Brandi finished talking. Apparently enjoying the attention, she spent the better part of two classes talking. I got as caught up in the story as the kids. “I been livin’ on the street in Portland. It’s a great way to lose weight. Maybe you wanna try it, Ms. M. “Really, though, I don’t recommend it. It’s pretty hard. I was cold most of the time. There was about six of us who hung together. We’d sleep at the Y, but ya can’t go there before eight at night, and ya gotta be out at seven. The library is warm, but we’d get thrown out after about an hour. Dunkin’ Donuts lets kids hang there when it’s not busy, but you can only stay there for a little while. Then you gotta move on and come back later. Same with the library. We’d go back a lot. But people in the library don’t like us. ‘That element,’ they call us. The bitchy ladies claimed we messed up the place. Sometimes they didn’t let us stay a whole hour at a time. “You can go to the soup kitchen once a day for lunch,” Brandi was telling the class. “Anything else ya eat is what ya can cop. It’s pretty easy to take stuff from some places. Some stuff is easier to lift, too. I ate candy, but it’s hard to get bread—it don’t fit in your pocket very well—and lunch meat and cheese, stuff like that’s almost impossible. They watch that stuff like a hawk.”
No wonder she’d lost so much weight, I thought—one meal a day and what food she could steal. “People rip each other off a lot,” she said. That’s why you join a family. There’s at least one big guy—it’s better if there’s two—so other families give you space. There’s a couple other kids who can take care of themselves,” Brandi smiled and pointed her thumbs toward herself. “Then you take in a couple of babies, kids who’d never make it without protection. One time I ripped off a leather coat from this dude. He was a real mean sucker, but I got it when he was passed out. Mike took it away from me, though. “Mike’s a cop—the best. He took away Rafe’s leather jacket from me because he said, when Rafe saw me with it, he’d cut me bad for sure. Then he got me a new coat. He bought it with his own money. And he’s got kids of his own to take care of. But they’re all boys. He said he liked me cuz I got ‘potential.’ The jacket’s cool. It’s in my locker—I’ll wear it to next class.” Brandi said that sometimes Mike bought her supper. He’d take her to Reilly’s, a favorite diner for Portland police, and buy her burgers and fries. “Some of the cops used to rag him that I was his penance. I don’t know what that meant. This one nasty cop, Steig, said I was his whore—sorry, Ms. M., but that’s a quote. It’s not true, though. Mike’s married and has a beautiful wife. I saw her once. He introduced me to her, and she was real nice. Mike is just a great cop.
“I wasn’t gonna come back. Even if it’s tough on the street, at least there ain’t a lotta dumb rules, people makin ya do stupid stuff, and school. It got so cold, though, that I went to the children’s shelter. Then I found out ya can’t stay more than two weeks. The DHS butts in and takes ya away. And I’ve had enough of goin’ to foster homes where all they want is the money and the hell with you. They said I’d better figure out if I wanted to get sent up by DHS or go back home voluntarily. I didn’t volunteer—ha, ha—but I decided to come back.”
Staying on the street all winter became too dangerous. Brandi said one boy she knew got so sick that he was hospitalized and almost died. Several students acted worried and vocalized their concerns. “Did the shelter ever get full?” Ethan asked. Usually spaced out or reading one of his fantasy books during class discussions, Ethan had been unusually attentively to Brandi’s tale. “Sometimes it did, yeah—especially when the weather got bad,” she answered. “Well, what did kids do then?” Ethan’s frown revealed his interest.
"Tough it out, mostly. I got closed out one night with a couple other kids. We found some cardboard and old newspapers, junk like that, and holed up under the old Million Dollar Bridge. That’s where the winos and some of the heavy-duty streets live...”
“Ah, that’s not true. Nobody would live outside under a bridge in the winter,” cut in Andy, an only child of professional parents and, from all I knew of the family, a boy who was loved, coddled, and indulged with designer-label clothes, gadgets, and trips to Florida and the Caribbean. “A lot you know about the real world, Demers,” scoffed Brandi. “Not everybody works or makes a lot of money. "
"What was it like under the bridge?” Jessica looked up from the notebook she was writing in. “How did the people keep warm?”
“There’s rocks, huge chunks of broken concrete, brush under there.
“People dragged in lots of pieces of wood, tin or some kind of metal, and boxes from refrigerators and stuff that they’ve built into these huts, sort of. They started fires in metal barrels or inside piles of rocks. We couldn’t go near them, but they didn’t bother us if we brought our own junk and set it up away from them.
“Anyway, before DHS brought me back, they got me some new clothes, too. The social worker lady was pretty cool. We went to the Mall, and she helped me pick out stuff. Then we went to Regis, and both of us had our hair cut. She paid for that herself. “So, here I am.” Here she was indeed, I thought—something of a heroine to many of the students, an alien to others.
4
By state law the school would help make any decisions about Brandi after her return. The guidance office set up Brandi’s Pupil Evaluation Team Plan (PET) for late winter. That’s when I had my first, and only, opportunity to meet her parents, all four of them. Brandi divided her time between her mother and her step-father, Mrs. and Mr. Barrett, and her father and her step-mother, Mr. and Mrs. Robb. Brandi’s mother was a small woman with nondescript features and light hair. I guessed her age to be about forty. Her husband, an attractive blond with an easy smile, seemed quite a bit younger. I learned that Mr. Barrett had full custody of his two children from a previous marriage, a boy of eight and a five-year-old girl. Brandi lived with them off and on after their marriage two years before, but the Barretts had put her out in the fall. Now she lived with her father and her step-mother.
Mr. Robb seemed considerably older than Brandi’s mother, perhaps fifty.He was short and heavy, with dark hair balding on top. His wife was of an indeterminate age; she looked as if she’d led a hard life. A couple of her teeth were missing, her skin was mottled, and her clothes were shabby.
During the conversation, I discovered that Brandi had been adopted when she was very young; thus, all four people discussing her future were not related to her by blood. Furthermore, she had spent several periods of time, totaling close to three years, in foster homes in Southern Maine. Mr. Robb and Mrs. Barrett, when still married to each other, sent her away because they thought Brandi was “disruptive” to the household. Their other children were older, they all worked, and she demanded too much of their time and attention. She acted “spoiled and fresh,” according to her mother. After the breakup of their marriage, the adoptive parents took turns keeping Brandi, a week or two with one, then a week or so with the other. When she became difficult to deal with, they put her in foster care. Now that Mr. Robb had remarried, he and his wife decided to try again. Mrs. Robb was home most of the time, and Brandi’s father worked sporadically, so they had more time to spend with her.
Mrs. Barrett said she doubted the situation would work. She refused to have Brandi visit her house after the run-away incident but expressed her willingness to let the Robbs do whatever they thought they could. “I don’t think you can handle her,” she said, looking down the table in the direction of Mr. Robb. “You couldn’t before, but go ahead and try.”
Mr. Robb said that things were different now. Mrs. Robb added, “He’s trying very hard with her. We both are.” Mrs. Barrett said nothing more; she seemed to be disinterested in the remainder of the meeting. Mr. Barrett smiled a lot and nodded his head occasionally, but he never spoke.
The PET meeting ended after an hour that included a review of the objectives of the past year, a discussion of the progress, or lack of, over the past year, and a set of expectations for completing the year. I left the meeting unclear where the girl Brandi fit into the plan outlined by the social worker, the school psychologist, an administrator, the teachers, and Brandi’s legal guardians. Previous to the PET meeting, I knew she had two sets of parents, but I had not known that she was adopted. I wondered how much, if anything, she knew about her biological parents and if it made any difference to her.
5
Toward the end of a school year, I usually asked my students to keep a writing journal. The writing could be about anything: personal thoughts, complaints, stories, poems, a daily schedule of tasks. I checked to make sure they wrote each day, but I didn’t read the journal unless invited to do so. Brandi told me she planned to use her journal to keep a record of her romances. Since her return to school after running away, she had begun dating and spending time with different boys. Her weight loss and new habit of cleaning and primping herself had attracted a following of seventh and eighth grade boys. A couple of the high school boys sometimes drove her to school and picked her up afterwards. Brandi’s attendance had improved as a result of all this attention.
One morning about a week before school let out for the summer, she entered the room, appearing agitated. She came in with her head down, shuffled her feet, and looked a little shaky. Her face was blotchy, her eyes were red, and her tank top was ripped at the shoulder. I asked her what had happened. “Nothin!” She emitted a long pause, then a sigh. “Everything sucks.”
“Do you want to talk about it with anybody?”
“Naw. Nobody can help.”
“How about writing about it?”
“That’s gay. What good’s it gonna do?”
“Maybe none. But maybe it will take some of the pressure off. Blow off some steam on paper, and maybe doing that will make you feel better.”
“It won’t. Believe me.” Brandi sat at her desk brooding for a while. She tapped a couple of fingers of one hand on the back of the other hand. Eventually she got out her journal—a loose-leaf notebook she had covered with pictures of male movie stars and models and decorated with different shades of nail polish. For the remainder of class, she wrote. Every time I glanced at her, she was busy pushing her pencil across the page. Great, I thought . It seemed to be calming her..
When the bell rang, she rose, walked to the door, and thrust the notebook at me. “Here. You can read it if you want. You don’t have to, though. It’s stupid.”
I said thank you, but she’d already left the room and was headed along the hall at a fast pace. At the end of the day I had a break and opened Brandi’s journal to read:
When I started school after vacation, I was having problems and started to drink again and overdose and other stuff. I had gotten adicted and I couldn’t stop. Until that is when I got realy sick and dizzy and passed out at my friend Deans house. I felt weird when I had woke up. To my surprise he never told anyone.
Brandi said nothing in response to Denise’s taunt. Instead she lunged at the taller girl. Falling to the floor in a jumble of painted fingernails and dirty shoes, the girls wrestled. Brandi, moving faster than I expected, given her bulk, gained the upper position. Sitting astride Denise, she commenced pummeling her head methodically, simultaneously bouncing on her belly. Brandi was a dirty little fighter. “So. I’m a fuckhead?” Brandi’s words came out in cadence with her bouncing. “Death to me? No way. I think. You’re gonna die. Greaseball.” On the last word, she grabbed a skein of Denise’s long hair and yanked, wrenching several strands from her scalp. “Bitch,” cried Denise. Saliva sprayed from her mouth. She squirmed but couldn’t dislodge Brandi. One of Denise’s sneakers fell from her gyrating foot and thumped to the floor. Brandi scooped it up and tossed it toward the bystanders congregating in the corridor outside the cafeteria. A big, blond boy caught the sneaker, and a couple of other boys cheered. Brandi held the hank of hair aloft. “Throw it,” somebody called. “Hey. Over here,” another boy yelled. “Okay, who wants it?” Brandi asked. Brandi played to her audience, who called out, whistled, and clapped in rhythm. She wound the hair into a wad, then cast it into the crowd. Blond boy caught it, and his buddies slapped him on the back. Brandi was quite a sight. She was big: not overly tall, but hefty for her height, about five feet four. Everything about her was round. Her face was full, with big cheeks, her nose was short and, if not exactly round, softened around the edges, and even her eyes, opened wide, sat like blue M &Ms on white paper plates. Her mouth was small and pouty, her lips covered in a light shade of gloss that, amazingly, still shimmered. Her smooth-skinned face glowed pale ivory with pink cheeks and sported a few freckles across the bridge of her nose. The good looks were there, just concealed behind the weight and the ugliness of her behavior.
Brandi’s arms and legs seemed shorter than they were because they were filled out with bulgy flesh, but no definition. Her thick body did not have a clear division of chest, waist, abdomen, and buttocks. All of the pieces more or less merged into one package, round and imposing. Her best feature was her hair. The color was lovely, although I wondered if she dyed it; later I learned it was natural. It was honey blond, a shimmering of various shades from very light brown to pale yellowish, the color that really looks like it was “touched by the sun.” The style, if you could call it that, was stunning, as well, but in a totally contrasting way. Brandi might have been striving for the spiked look, but either the fight or no idea of how to accomplish the effect resulted in a strange hair-do. The result was a mass of uneven clumps of hair protruding from her head, some of it matted, some of it separated into strands, all of it looking less like hair than a dirty mop. Brandi was one tough cookie. Finally Bob Lemieux, a burly industrial arts teacher, arrived and pulled Brandi off Denise. Struggling and sniping at her captors, Brandi had a nasty word or two for the bystanders in the crowd. As she moved by me, Brandi flashed a grimace in my direction and asked, “What you looking at, bitch?”
After the crowd broke up and headed to class, I recalled a reference to her a few days prior to the fight. At the beginning of lunch period on that particular day, I had walked into the girls' lavatory. A favorite hangout, it served as an informal lounge, snack bar, and beauty salon. I found no one there but noticed a line of graffiti strung along one wall. The words blazed in cherry-bright lipstick across the ocher cinder blocks: “Death to the Bitch—Your going to die—Brandi is a Fuckhead.”
School policy required any personal threats be reported to the principal, so I had notified the office. Shocking as the words sounded, students sometimes marked up walls with nasty, cruel comments, especially if more than one person collaborated or if one kid dared another. I had wondered who this Brandi person might be that she could elicit so extreme a statement. Having just learned the answer, I realized that Denise must have been the author, and Brandi had just inflicted her style of retaliation.
2
Several weeks into the term, Brandi transferred to my teaching team. She always dressed in jeans. At school there was a sort of teen-age fashion cult concerning the proper design, fabric, color, and accessories for jeans. Despite her extra weight, Brandi was as conscious of the style as any girl her age. She owned a wardrobe of jeans that ran the gamut of adolescent fashion-consciousness: flares, bells, straight legs, baggies, low-risers. As for her tops and her shoes, Brandi also showed herself a savvy dresser. The tops hung loose, in an attempt to hide her bulk, and were either sweaters or of jersey material. She wore both short-sleeved and long-sleeved tops, mostly in pale or, more likely, just faded colors: light blue, beige, lavender, green. She also owned the inevitable gray sweatshirt; she could wear that over anything, and it served as a sort of uniform for both boys and girls—jeans and a gray sweatshirt, a safe, blend-into-the-crowd kind of outfit. Although she owned acceptable Nikes, she preferred a pair of black leather platform shoes with laces and rounded toes. They increased her height at least two inches.
Each day in class I never knew what kind of mood Brandi might be in or how she would act. Some days she arrived sullen and remained quiet and distant for the entire class, though these occasions happened infrequently. More commonly she stormed into the room, her voice leading the way. Discord and unpleasantness followed her, then hung, cloud-like, over her head, a personal little storm.
At rare times she entered the room calmly, like most of the kids. One such day I instructed the students to write a personal narrative. “You’re not going to make us read these out loud, are you?” Brandi asked. When I assured her that only I would read the essays, she immediately set to work, writing for most of the class time. When she finished her composition, Brandi set down her pencil and lay her head on the desk. I left her alone until I called for the papers. Rising, she handed me her narrative without saying a word and left the room.
I forgot about her paper until the evening, when I was reading her class’s work and picked hers from the pile:
Each day I wake up and wonder will any body appreciate me for who I am. Thats the question! I look at myself in the mirror. Reflecting off me is a person wanting high education. I look at myself and wonder am I any good for someone. I look at other girls my age always trying to be like them. Wanting to be cool in my own way. Every time I look at myself striving to be better each day. Taking nonsense and sense and putting it together and becomes a life for others. I wonder will I be like them? I know that each day I get up and go to school. Everybody makes fun of me always saying there better than me. Maybe they are. I want to go to collage and my years in school are going fast. I know I’ll be what I am forever. I’ll be that person wanting more in my life. Will I ever get married or live in a rich mansion? No one can predict the future. But I know that if I was pretty and popular, guys would like me. I know somewhere there is a person just perfect for me. I wonder will I ever go to the prom or be popular?
Setting the paper on my desk, I thought about the disparity between Brandi the thick-skinned tough and Brandi the insecure twelve-year-old. A sensitive girl dwelled in there somewhere, and I vowed to scratch the surface to find out who appeared. I returned to school after Thanksgiving vacation, but Brandi did not. After three days, the seventh grade guidance counselor, Elaine Fowler, informed me that Brandi had run away from home. The parents did not know where she was, and, according to the counselor, they probably wouldn’t look for her because, “She’s run off in the past and always come back when she’s ready.” Elaine guessed that she had gone to Portland and joined the fairly large number of adolescent runaways who lived on the street, panhandled, andvisited the soup kitchen for one meal a day. “How will you find her?” I asked. “Hey, the parents don’t care. I tend to agree with them. She’ll show up when she’s ready.”
“Well, don’t you have to report this to the authorities? Doesn’t the school have a responsibility for her safety? "
"I’ve contacted the Department of Human Services. They take it from there—at least till she returns. Then we’ll have to meet with the DHS caseworker, her parents, maybe a social worker and a psychologist, the whole nine yards. "
"It seems so cold-blooded to let a twelve-year-old child fend for herself like that...” I began. Elaine cut me off. “Hey, nobody permitted her to go—she took off herself. Besides, this kid is a pain to everybody. She made it clear she has no use for us. I’ve got plenty of good kids who appreciate what I try to do for them. Besides, I say good riddance to bad rubbish.” She turned from me and headed toward her office
I taught my classes, noting each day that Brandi did not return. I knew I would hear from the principal when he got any news about her. As Christmas break approached and still Brandi had not appeared at school, I wondered what she was doing.
3
School resumed in January, and Brandi continued to remain among the missing. At the end of the month she returned, without fanfare. On a Thursday she sauntered into my classroom to a cacophony of comments and questions from the other students. “Hey, look who’s back. "
"Wow—where ya been, man? "
"Geez, I thought you were the smart one. But you came back, dummy. What’d you do that for? "
"Lookin’ good, lady, lookin’ real good.” This comment came from the loud mouth of Kevin Wiley, a big, heavy-set boy descended from a long line of woodsmen. He considered school a place to park himself until he turned sixteen. Kevin often waxed eloquent on the relative merits of chain saws, splitters, skidders, and cherry pickers, while he kept one of his pale green eyes perpetually focused for attractive girls. Brandi’s appearance startled me as much as it did my students. I was surprised by her return to school, more surprised by her looks. She was noticeably thinner, twenty pounds thinner, I guessed. With bulk reduced, her body had definition: hips, waist, and breasts. The round face had disappeared, replaced with more of an oval; high cheekbones stood out, and her lips appeared fuller. Her eyes sparkled as before, although they took on more prominence in the slimmer face. Somebody had styled her hair, which practically squeaked of clean and lay over her head in short, loose curls. The morning sun caught the golden highlights.
Brandi strutted in new clothes that fit properly and looked good. She wore jeans, a traditional cut that neither bagged nor trailed on the floor. Her shoes were black platforms with laces, but lower and less clunky than her old ones. A long-sleeved, light blue sweater enhanced the blue of her eyes and contrasted nicely with the red-gold of her hair. Brandi looked pretty. The class thought so, too. I noticed them watching her while she walked across the room to my desk. “Hey, Ms. M., I’m here.”
Both the boys and the girls were curious about the “new” Brandi. Everyone, it seemed, wanted to know where she’d been, what she’d been doing, what was going on. “You been gone so long, I thought you died. Ha. I guess you didn’t though. "
"Somebody told me you been in Portland. I bet you ain’t been nowhere.
You just been home playin’ hooky. "
"You really been livin’ on the street? "
"What’s it like?”
Fascinated by her unexpected disappearance, her classmates asked if Brandi could share her experience of running away and living on her own. I asked Brandi if she wanted to tell us what had happened to her. She shrugged and said, “Okay,” but I thought her smile belied the blasé response. Most of the students wanted to hear Brandi’s story. I anticipated many questions, so I told the class to save comments and questions until Brandi finished talking. Apparently enjoying the attention, she spent the better part of two classes talking. I got as caught up in the story as the kids. “I been livin’ on the street in Portland. It’s a great way to lose weight. Maybe you wanna try it, Ms. M. “Really, though, I don’t recommend it. It’s pretty hard. I was cold most of the time. There was about six of us who hung together. We’d sleep at the Y, but ya can’t go there before eight at night, and ya gotta be out at seven. The library is warm, but we’d get thrown out after about an hour. Dunkin’ Donuts lets kids hang there when it’s not busy, but you can only stay there for a little while. Then you gotta move on and come back later. Same with the library. We’d go back a lot. But people in the library don’t like us. ‘That element,’ they call us. The bitchy ladies claimed we messed up the place. Sometimes they didn’t let us stay a whole hour at a time. “You can go to the soup kitchen once a day for lunch,” Brandi was telling the class. “Anything else ya eat is what ya can cop. It’s pretty easy to take stuff from some places. Some stuff is easier to lift, too. I ate candy, but it’s hard to get bread—it don’t fit in your pocket very well—and lunch meat and cheese, stuff like that’s almost impossible. They watch that stuff like a hawk.”
No wonder she’d lost so much weight, I thought—one meal a day and what food she could steal. “People rip each other off a lot,” she said. That’s why you join a family. There’s at least one big guy—it’s better if there’s two—so other families give you space. There’s a couple other kids who can take care of themselves,” Brandi smiled and pointed her thumbs toward herself. “Then you take in a couple of babies, kids who’d never make it without protection. One time I ripped off a leather coat from this dude. He was a real mean sucker, but I got it when he was passed out. Mike took it away from me, though. “Mike’s a cop—the best. He took away Rafe’s leather jacket from me because he said, when Rafe saw me with it, he’d cut me bad for sure. Then he got me a new coat. He bought it with his own money. And he’s got kids of his own to take care of. But they’re all boys. He said he liked me cuz I got ‘potential.’ The jacket’s cool. It’s in my locker—I’ll wear it to next class.” Brandi said that sometimes Mike bought her supper. He’d take her to Reilly’s, a favorite diner for Portland police, and buy her burgers and fries. “Some of the cops used to rag him that I was his penance. I don’t know what that meant. This one nasty cop, Steig, said I was his whore—sorry, Ms. M., but that’s a quote. It’s not true, though. Mike’s married and has a beautiful wife. I saw her once. He introduced me to her, and she was real nice. Mike is just a great cop.
“I wasn’t gonna come back. Even if it’s tough on the street, at least there ain’t a lotta dumb rules, people makin ya do stupid stuff, and school. It got so cold, though, that I went to the children’s shelter. Then I found out ya can’t stay more than two weeks. The DHS butts in and takes ya away. And I’ve had enough of goin’ to foster homes where all they want is the money and the hell with you. They said I’d better figure out if I wanted to get sent up by DHS or go back home voluntarily. I didn’t volunteer—ha, ha—but I decided to come back.”
Staying on the street all winter became too dangerous. Brandi said one boy she knew got so sick that he was hospitalized and almost died. Several students acted worried and vocalized their concerns. “Did the shelter ever get full?” Ethan asked. Usually spaced out or reading one of his fantasy books during class discussions, Ethan had been unusually attentively to Brandi’s tale. “Sometimes it did, yeah—especially when the weather got bad,” she answered. “Well, what did kids do then?” Ethan’s frown revealed his interest.
"Tough it out, mostly. I got closed out one night with a couple other kids. We found some cardboard and old newspapers, junk like that, and holed up under the old Million Dollar Bridge. That’s where the winos and some of the heavy-duty streets live...”
“Ah, that’s not true. Nobody would live outside under a bridge in the winter,” cut in Andy, an only child of professional parents and, from all I knew of the family, a boy who was loved, coddled, and indulged with designer-label clothes, gadgets, and trips to Florida and the Caribbean. “A lot you know about the real world, Demers,” scoffed Brandi. “Not everybody works or makes a lot of money. "
"What was it like under the bridge?” Jessica looked up from the notebook she was writing in. “How did the people keep warm?”
“There’s rocks, huge chunks of broken concrete, brush under there.
“People dragged in lots of pieces of wood, tin or some kind of metal, and boxes from refrigerators and stuff that they’ve built into these huts, sort of. They started fires in metal barrels or inside piles of rocks. We couldn’t go near them, but they didn’t bother us if we brought our own junk and set it up away from them.
“Anyway, before DHS brought me back, they got me some new clothes, too. The social worker lady was pretty cool. We went to the Mall, and she helped me pick out stuff. Then we went to Regis, and both of us had our hair cut. She paid for that herself. “So, here I am.” Here she was indeed, I thought—something of a heroine to many of the students, an alien to others.
4
By state law the school would help make any decisions about Brandi after her return. The guidance office set up Brandi’s Pupil Evaluation Team Plan (PET) for late winter. That’s when I had my first, and only, opportunity to meet her parents, all four of them. Brandi divided her time between her mother and her step-father, Mrs. and Mr. Barrett, and her father and her step-mother, Mr. and Mrs. Robb. Brandi’s mother was a small woman with nondescript features and light hair. I guessed her age to be about forty. Her husband, an attractive blond with an easy smile, seemed quite a bit younger. I learned that Mr. Barrett had full custody of his two children from a previous marriage, a boy of eight and a five-year-old girl. Brandi lived with them off and on after their marriage two years before, but the Barretts had put her out in the fall. Now she lived with her father and her step-mother.
Mr. Robb seemed considerably older than Brandi’s mother, perhaps fifty.He was short and heavy, with dark hair balding on top. His wife was of an indeterminate age; she looked as if she’d led a hard life. A couple of her teeth were missing, her skin was mottled, and her clothes were shabby.
During the conversation, I discovered that Brandi had been adopted when she was very young; thus, all four people discussing her future were not related to her by blood. Furthermore, she had spent several periods of time, totaling close to three years, in foster homes in Southern Maine. Mr. Robb and Mrs. Barrett, when still married to each other, sent her away because they thought Brandi was “disruptive” to the household. Their other children were older, they all worked, and she demanded too much of their time and attention. She acted “spoiled and fresh,” according to her mother. After the breakup of their marriage, the adoptive parents took turns keeping Brandi, a week or two with one, then a week or so with the other. When she became difficult to deal with, they put her in foster care. Now that Mr. Robb had remarried, he and his wife decided to try again. Mrs. Robb was home most of the time, and Brandi’s father worked sporadically, so they had more time to spend with her.
Mrs. Barrett said she doubted the situation would work. She refused to have Brandi visit her house after the run-away incident but expressed her willingness to let the Robbs do whatever they thought they could. “I don’t think you can handle her,” she said, looking down the table in the direction of Mr. Robb. “You couldn’t before, but go ahead and try.”
Mr. Robb said that things were different now. Mrs. Robb added, “He’s trying very hard with her. We both are.” Mrs. Barrett said nothing more; she seemed to be disinterested in the remainder of the meeting. Mr. Barrett smiled a lot and nodded his head occasionally, but he never spoke.
The PET meeting ended after an hour that included a review of the objectives of the past year, a discussion of the progress, or lack of, over the past year, and a set of expectations for completing the year. I left the meeting unclear where the girl Brandi fit into the plan outlined by the social worker, the school psychologist, an administrator, the teachers, and Brandi’s legal guardians. Previous to the PET meeting, I knew she had two sets of parents, but I had not known that she was adopted. I wondered how much, if anything, she knew about her biological parents and if it made any difference to her.
5
Toward the end of a school year, I usually asked my students to keep a writing journal. The writing could be about anything: personal thoughts, complaints, stories, poems, a daily schedule of tasks. I checked to make sure they wrote each day, but I didn’t read the journal unless invited to do so. Brandi told me she planned to use her journal to keep a record of her romances. Since her return to school after running away, she had begun dating and spending time with different boys. Her weight loss and new habit of cleaning and primping herself had attracted a following of seventh and eighth grade boys. A couple of the high school boys sometimes drove her to school and picked her up afterwards. Brandi’s attendance had improved as a result of all this attention.
One morning about a week before school let out for the summer, she entered the room, appearing agitated. She came in with her head down, shuffled her feet, and looked a little shaky. Her face was blotchy, her eyes were red, and her tank top was ripped at the shoulder. I asked her what had happened. “Nothin!” She emitted a long pause, then a sigh. “Everything sucks.”
“Do you want to talk about it with anybody?”
“Naw. Nobody can help.”
“How about writing about it?”
“That’s gay. What good’s it gonna do?”
“Maybe none. But maybe it will take some of the pressure off. Blow off some steam on paper, and maybe doing that will make you feel better.”
“It won’t. Believe me.” Brandi sat at her desk brooding for a while. She tapped a couple of fingers of one hand on the back of the other hand. Eventually she got out her journal—a loose-leaf notebook she had covered with pictures of male movie stars and models and decorated with different shades of nail polish. For the remainder of class, she wrote. Every time I glanced at her, she was busy pushing her pencil across the page. Great, I thought . It seemed to be calming her..
When the bell rang, she rose, walked to the door, and thrust the notebook at me. “Here. You can read it if you want. You don’t have to, though. It’s stupid.”
I said thank you, but she’d already left the room and was headed along the hall at a fast pace. At the end of the day I had a break and opened Brandi’s journal to read:
When I started school after vacation, I was having problems and started to drink again and overdose and other stuff. I had gotten adicted and I couldn’t stop. Until that is when I got realy sick and dizzy and passed out at my friend Deans house. I felt weird when I had woke up. To my surprise he never told anyone.